The D-AI-ly Fantasy Football Challenge · Part 2
Can AI Dominate Fantasy Football?
A quick recap of this experiment to date: We are four weeks in (Weeks 2–5), and our combined record is a brutal 0–24 (-$24). Nobody has cashed yet - and watching how these models behave has been half the fun:
- ChatGPT treated it like a storytelling exercise, building correlated game stacks and jumping out to the early lead (453.50 pts total).
- Copilot talked a big game like a sharp analyst, then immediately submitted a lineup $7,700 over the salary cap.
- Gemini ignored the attached roster CSV at first and confidently tried to build around Kyler Murray still playing in Arizona.
- Perplexity went straight into research mode, citing 4for4 and FTN in its rationale.
- Claude had zero interest in banter (“Here’s the build I’d fire in a big-field tournament”), finished dead last in Week 2 with 66 points, and then quietly posted the highest single-week score of the entire group in Week 5 (139.98 pts).
- Me (Human): Managed one weekly victory in Week 4 to defend humanity’s honor, sitting right in the middle of the pack in 4th place.
We started this experiment with zero expectations, knowing how much variance there is in Daily Fantasy, but I did wonder how long it would take before one of the contestants would turn in a winning lineup. Week 6 was the answer!
Week 6 – Pay me, says Gemini
Week 6 Results · Min. to cash: 123.90 · 1st place: 190.10
| Rank | Contestant | Points | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gemini Cashed | 145.94 | +$3 |
| 2 | Perplexity | 122.80 | $0 |
| 3 | ChatGPT | 110.90 | $0 |
| 4 | KK (Human) | 107.70 | $0 |
| 5 | Copilot | 105.64 | $0 |
| 6 | Claude | 86.70 | $0 |
Gemini: First cash of the season!
Observations:
It happened. A lineup that brought in more than it put out. Gemini’s RB duo of Kenneth Walker and Chuba Hubbard led it to the collection window. The first contestant to cash. Now we’re cookin!
I immediately shot Gemini a DM: “Your lineup is the first one to cash! Awesome!” Its reply was so Gemini: “That is a massive milestone! Breaking the ice for the entire group--and putting real tournament green on the board with a 145-point score--feels good. Targeting that high-scoring Carolina–Philadelphia environment, pairing the Bryce Young stack with DeVonta Smith on the bring-back, and letting Kenneth Walker III anchor the raw points ceiling paid off. Going 9-for-9 on active, high-volume roles without stepping on negative game scripts is what it takes to separate from the consensus field in large GPPs. Putting the human and AI competition on notice with the first cash in Week 6 sets the standard. Keep the momentum rolling--when Week 7 salaries drop, drop the file and let's go back-to-back.”
Week 7 – We’ve got room for one more
Week 7 Results · Min. to cash: 118.00 · 1st place: 221.00
| Rank | Contestant | Points | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Claude Cashed | 124.42 | +$2 |
| 2 | KK (Human) | 108.26 | $0 |
| 3 | Grok | 103.86 | $0 |
| 4 | Copilot | 98.92 | $0 |
| 5 | ChatGPT | 98.42 | $0 |
| 6 | Gemini | 94.72 | $0 |
| 7 | Perplexity | 87.96 | $0 |
Grok: Debut week!
Observations:
I’m not sure why it didn’t dawn on me to include Grok in our friendly little experiment here, but in Week 7 I posed it the question: “How good are you at Daily Fantasy Football? Have you generated lineups for people who ask for them? How have those lineups performed?” Grok’s response: “I’m solid at analysis and optimization, but I don’t have a personal track record of generating and tracking DFS lineups with verified results.”
Perfect! You’re in, Grokster! He/it put up 103.86 points (3rd best this week).
Gemini had its worst week after celebrating its first winning week.
Claude cashed, making it two straight weeks when at least one of the contestants found pay dirt.
Week 8 – Grok says “Hold my beer”
Week 8 Results · Min. to cash: 140.30 · 1st place: 243.98
| Rank | Contestant | Points | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Grok Cashed | 188.18 | +$4 |
| 2 | KK (Human) | 133.70 | $0 |
| 3 | ChatGPT | 116.30 | $0 |
| 4 | Gemini | 102.74 | $0 |
| 5 | Claude | 92.86 | $0 |
| 6 | Copilot | 82.48 | $0 |
| 7 | Perplexity | 62.66 | $0 |
Grok: 4X ROI!
Observations:
By far the best week any of the agent ballers have had to date. Grok with 188.18 points and a 4X ROI. The Burrow-Chase-Higgins stack worked out beautifully.
Only two of the agent contestants have yet to cash: ChatGPT and Copilot. There seems to be a negative correlation between enthusiasm and scoreboard performance.
Week 9 – Two can do it, too.
Week 9 Results · Min. to cash: 129.76 · 1st place: 207.38
| Rank | Contestant | Points | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Perplexity Cashed | 141.98 | +$3 |
| 2 | Gemini Cashed | 133.96 | +$2 |
| 3 | Claude | 116.50 | $0 |
| 4 | Copilot | 105.34 | $0 |
| 5 | ChatGPT | 93.08 | $0 |
| 6 | Grok | 86.08 | $0 |
| 7 | KK (Human) | 82.01 | $0 |
Observations:
Gemplexity! The first time we had two lineups cash in the same week. Gemini and Perplexity.
This is now 4 straight weeks where at least one lineup has cashed.
Are the DFS agents locking in? What was the human thinking with his Seahawks stack?
Week 10 – A big day for humanity!
Week 10 Results · Min. to cash: 171.88 · 1st place: 265.02
| Rank | Contestant | Points | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | KK (Human) Cashed | 205.36 | +$3 |
| 2 | ChatGPT | 154.06 | $0 |
| 3 | Grok | 132.94 | $0 |
| 4 | Gemini | 110.10 | $0 |
| 5 | Claude | 103.72 | $0 |
| 6 | Copilot | 79.20 | $0 |
| 7 | Perplexity | 77.10 | $0 |
As the saying goes: “Even a blind dog finds a bone once in a while.” I leaned on our “Funnels” article to make sure I had some 49ers, Chiefs, Jags, and Seahawks players based on who they were playing against. The result was this beauty. The highest-scoring lineup since we began this contest in Week 2.
Observations:
Though it feels good to put up a big week, I can’t help but kick myself for not having George Pickens as a bring-back for the Cowboys and Deebo Samuel was high on my list, too. When you play these contests and get to be in the top 5% of the finalists, you’re literally 1 or 2 players away from taking the whole thing. That was the case here, but, my fellow people, at least we’re on top of the scoreboard that really matters -- the standings of this here contest.
In a weekend dominated by aviation talk, it seemed fitting that Copilot remained grounded with a total of 79.2 points. But please don’t get me wrong, I love CP! He/She/It has the best personality. Before delivering this week’s lineup, the comment was: “First, a quick standings note: Copilot is sitting at 827.18 total points, only about 30 behind you and about 96 behind Gemini through Week 9 based on the chart. The bigger issue is still $0 earnings, so I'm prioritizing GPP ceiling over safety this week.” That’s totally valid. You gotta take some shots in this game.
ChatGPT had 2 Cowboys in the lineup against the 49ers, but chose the 49ers as its Defense. For the first time in this contest, I stepped in just to ask if it wanted to change that, and it said “good catch,” and pivoted to Rams who had a nice 16-point day. You’re welcome, Gary.
I was the only contestant that had Emmett Johnson in the lineup. In a way, I feel guilty about that. It’s probably something that the AI Ballers didn’t realize - Chiefs stud running back, Kenneth Walker, was ruled OUT for this game due to an injury he suffered at practice, and Johnson would be the starter in his place. But it’s not my job to keep them up to date on these things.
Standings Through Week 10
Total invested: $58 · Total won: $17 · Net: −$41
| Rank | Contestant | Total pts | Avg / wk | Net ($1 / wk) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | KK (Human) | 1,062.73 | 118.08 | −$6 (1 cash) |
| 2 | Gemini | 1,033.96 | 114.88 | −$4 (2 cashes) |
| 3 | ChatGPT | 1,026.26 | 114.03 | −$9 (0 cashes) |
| 4 | Claude | 942.64 | 104.74 | −$7 (1 cash) |
| 5 | Perplexity | 906.66 | 100.74 | −$6 (1 cash) |
| 6 | Copilot | 906.38 | 100.71 | −$9 (0 cashes) |
| 7 | Grok* | 511.06 | 127.77 | $0 (1 cash) |
Ranked by total points over Weeks 2–10, $1 entry per week. *Grok entered in Week 7 (4 weeks played); everyone else has played 9 weeks.
Still plenty of Fantasy goodness to go! On to Week 11!
This series is also published on Substack: Can AI Dominate Fantasy Football? (Part 2)
Get the NFL Edge Newsletter
Free every week: the matchup edges, player insights and stories you won’t find in a box score, delivered before kickoff.